Technical documentation

Calculation Methodology

A complete technical account of how VSME OS calculates greenhouse gas emissions — the data sources used, the formulas applied, and the assumptions made. Designed to satisfy auditor enquiries and ESG due diligence.

GHG Protocol

Corporate Standard

ISO 14064-1:2018

Quantification standard

EU Voluntary Standard

Del. Reg. (EU) 2026/1560 · built from VSME 2025/1710

CSRD ESRS E1

Climate disclosures

1. Core Emission Calculation Formula

All emissions in VSME OS are calculated using the standard activity-based methodology defined by the GHG Protocol:

Emissions (kgCO₂e) = Activity Data × Emission Factor

Where activity data is the quantity of a resource consumed (e.g. kWh of electricity, litres of diesel, km flown) and the emission factor converts that quantity into kg of CO₂ equivalent (kgCO₂e), accounting for all relevant greenhouse gases (CO₂, CH₄, N₂O, HFCs etc.) expressed as CO₂ equivalents. Refrigerants are converted here with IPCC AR6 GWP100 values; every other factor is used as its issuing body publishes it, already in CO₂e.

Emissions from multiple sources are summed to produce scope totals. The grand total is the sum of Scope 1 + Scope 2 (location-based) + Scope 3 emissions, expressed in kgCO₂e or tCO₂e (1 tCO₂e = 1,000 kgCO₂e).

Carbon Intensity Metrics: Where annual revenue is provided, VSME OS calculates two intensity metrics. The primary metric is kgCO₂e per million units of revenue currency (e.g. kgCO₂e / M€), aligned with ESRS E1-6 of the 2023 ESRS (GHG intensity of net revenues) and used for cross-supplier comparison. The secondary metric is kgCO₂e per actual EUR of revenue (4 decimal places), useful for absolute cost-of-carbon calculations. Both are shown on Page 1 of the generated report.

2. Emission Factor Databases by Country

VSME OS uses country-specific emission factor databasesrather than a single global average. The correct national database is selected automatically based on the supplier's declared country of operations. This is critical for accuracy: France's electricity grid (predominantly nuclear) has a factor of 0.0388 kgCO₂e/kWh, while Poland's (predominantly coal) is 0.566 kgCO₂e/kWh — a 15× difference that would produce a fundamentally misleading report if the wrong factor were applied.

Country / RegionPrimary DatabaseGrid Factor (kgCO₂e/kWh)
FranceADEME Base Carbone V23.11, element 43642 (2024 mix): plant combustion + network losses, upstream excluded0.0388
United KingdomDEFRA/DESNZ 20260.14395
GermanyUBA Climate Change 16/20260.352
SpainEEA, GHG intensity of electricity generation (2024)0.125
ItalyEEA, GHG intensity of electricity generation (2024)0.206
NetherlandsEEA, GHG intensity of electricity generation (2024)0.245
BelgiumEEA, GHG intensity of electricity generation (2024)0.155
SwedenEEA, GHG intensity of electricity generation (2024)0.006
PolandEEA, GHG intensity of electricity generation (2024)0.566
USAEPA eGRID2023 (Jan 2025, AR5 GWP)0.35
CanadaECCC National Inventory Report 2025, Table A13-1 consumption intensity (2023)0.11
AustraliaNGA Factors 2026 (DCCEEW)0.59
South AfricaESKOM / Department of Energy SA 20230.928
IndiaCEA CO2 Baseline Database v22.00.675
ChinaMEE/NBS national electricity CO2 emission factor (2023)0.5306
Other (default)IEA Emissions Factors 2025 (2024 provisional data)0.445

69 countries are supported. For countries where national grid operators do not publish standalone emission factors, IEA values are applied and labelled as such in the report. Each source publishes on its own cycle; newer editions that exist but are not yet applied are listed under factor currency below.

1

3. Scope 1 — Direct Emissions

Scope 1 covers emissions from sources owned or controlled by the reporting organisation. VSME OS covers three Scope 1 categories:

3.1 Stationary Combustion (Fuels for heating/energy)

Activity SourceUnitFactor (kgCO₂e)SourceNotes
Natural GaskWh PCS (as billed)0.181ADEME Base Carbone V23.11 (2026)Combustion only. Element 37133 (2022 average mix, per kWh PCS). The energy table converts to net (PCI).
Heating Oillitres2.68ADEME Base Carbone V23.11 (2026)Combustion only. Element 14087 (fioul domestique).
Propane / LPGlitres1.54ADEME Base Carbone V23.11 (2026)Combustion only. Element 13560.

Scope 1 is combustion only: CO₂, CH₄ and N₂O released when the fuel is burned, as ADEME publishes it in the "Combustion" line of each element. Upstream emissions from extracting, refining and transporting the fuel are Scope 3 Category 3 under the GHG Protocol and are not quantified by this product. Until November 2026 these factors included the upstream share, which overstated Scope 1 by roughly a fifth; declarations already submitted keep the factors they were filed with.

3.2 Mobile Combustion (Company-owned vehicles)

Covers fuel used in vehicles owned or leased by the company (fleet vehicles). Employee personal vehicles reimbursed per km are reported in Scope 3.

Activity SourceUnitFactor (kgCO₂e)SourceNotes
Diesel (fleet)litres2.5ADEME Base Carbone V23.11 (2026)Road diesel B7, combustion only. Element 48823.
Petrol / Gasolinelitres2.06ADEME Base Carbone V23.11 (2026)Petrol E10, combustion only. Element 48825.

3.3 Fugitive Emissions (Refrigerants)

Refrigerant leaks are high-impact Scope 1 emissions due to the very high Global Warming Potential (GWP) of hydrofluorocarbons. Factors are GWP100 values from the IPCC Sixth Assessment Report (AR6, Working Group I, Chapter 7, Table 7.SM.7), the values ESRS E1 asks for. Blends are computed from their component gases by mass. Equipment labels and the EU F-Gas Regulation use older AR4-based figures, so a label may show a lower number.

Activity SourceUnitFactor (kgCO₂e)SourceNotes
R410Akg2,256IPCC AR6 GWP100Common AC refrigerant. 50% R32 + 50% R125.
R32kg771IPCC AR6 GWP100Newer AC refrigerant, lower GWP than R410A
R134akg1,530IPCC AR6 GWP100Vehicle and light commercial AC
R404Akg4,728IPCC AR6 GWP100Commercial refrigeration. Being phased out under the EU F-Gas Regulation.

EU F-Gas Regulation Note: R404A is being phased out under Regulation (EU) 2024/573, which replaced Regulation (EU) 517/2014. Organisations using R404A should be planning transition to lower-GWP alternatives. Reporting refrigerant top-ups is legally required for systems ≥3 tonnes CO₂e charge under EU F-Gas Regulation.

4. Scope 2 — Indirect Energy Emissions

Scope 2 covers emissions from purchased electricity, heat, steam, and cooling. VSME OS reports both methods wherever a market-based figure can be produced honestly. The location-based figure is the one in every total; the market-based figure is shown beside it, never instead of it. The difference between them is the single most misunderstood thing about Scope 2:

4.1 Location-Based Method

Uses the average emission factor for the national or regional electricity grid in the country where the energy was consumed. See Section 2 for the full country-specific factor table. This is the default method and the one most commonly requested by buyers, who use a supplier's emissions in their own Scope 3 Category 1 (purchased goods and services).

4.2 Market-Based Method — reported alongside location-based

The market-based method uses the emission factor attached to the specific energy contract: zero for electricity the supplier declares as covered by a Guarantee of Origin, a REC or a PPA, and the country's published residual mix factor (AIB European Residual Mix) for everything not covered by one. District heating and cooling carry the same factor under both methods.

The residual mix matters: once every certificate in a country has been stripped out of the pool, what is left is dirtier than the grid average — so the market-based figure is frequently higher than the location-based one, dramatically so in countries that export most of their guarantees of origin. Zero-rating contracted electricity and leaving the rest at the grid average would double-count every renewable kWh, and VSME OS does not do it.

Three rules govern what appears on the report:

  • Totals stay location-based. Scope 2 in the totals and the grand total is always location-based — the figure the EU Voluntary Standard asks for at B3 §33 — so methods are never mixed in one number.
  • Market-based is shown only where it can be built. Where AIB publishes no residual mix for the country (most countries outside Europe) and some electricity is uncontracted, the report says the market-based figure is not reportable rather than inventing one.
  • The basis is stated. AIB residual mixes are published in CO₂, not CO₂e, and the report says so beside the figure rather than restating it.

A renewable contract is also disclosed as the renewable share of energy consumption in the B3 §32 energy table. Buyers use a supplier's figures in their own Scope 3 Category 1 (purchased goods and services).

4.3 District Heating and Cooling

Activity SourceUnitFactor (kgCO₂e)SourceNotes
District HeatingkWhCountry-specificEuroheat & Power 2023Derived from country grid mix and typical plant efficiency
District CoolingkWhCountry-specificIEA methodologyGrid factor ÷ Coefficient of Performance (COP 3.5)

5. Scope 3 — Value Chain Emissions

Scope 3 covers indirect emissions in a company's value chain. VSME OS currently covers Category 6 (Business Travel) and Category 7 (Employee Commuting), which together represent the most material Scope 3 sources for the majority of SME service businesses.

5.1 Business Travel — Ground (Category 6)

Activity SourceUnitFactor (kgCO₂e)SourceNotes
Employee Vehicles (Grey Fleet)km0.16591DEFRA / DESNZ 2026Average car, unknown fuel, per vehicle-km. Total annual km across all grey fleet drivers.
Rail / Train TravelkmCountry-specificDEFRA / DESNZ 2026 + national databasesUK: 0.03092 · France: 0.0058 · Germany: 0.023 · Poland: 0.037. Varies by grid mix.
Hotel StaysnightsCountry-specificDEFRA / DESNZ 2026 + CHSB 2024 fallbackkgCO₂e per room-night. France 6.7 · Spain 7.0 · UK 10.4 · Germany 13.2 · Italy 14.3 · US 16.1 · India 58.9. Countries DEFRA does not publish fall back to 28.0 — see disclosure below.

5.2 Business Travel — Aviation (Category 6)

VSME OS splits flights into short-haul (under 3,700 km) and long-haul (3,700 km and above). This split matters because:

  • Short-haul flights are less fuel-efficient per km (more fuel consumed during takeoff and landing relative to total flight distance)
  • Long-haul flights spend more time at cruising altitude where Radiative Forcing is most significant
  • DEFRA/DESNZ 2026 publishes separate factors for each category, and using a blended average misstates emissions for travellers weighted to one haul type
Activity SourceUnitFactor (kgCO₂e)SourceNotes
Short-Haul Flights (<3,700 km)pkm0.12786DEFRA / DESNZ 2026Average passenger, with radiative forcing. Short-haul to/from UK.
Long-Haul Flights (≥3,700 km)pkm0.15282DEFRA / DESNZ 2026Average passenger (all cabin classes), with radiative forcing. Higher per passenger-km than short-haul in the 2026 series — this is what the published table states.

Radiative Forcing (RF) Multiplier

Aviation emissions at altitude cause additional warming beyond CO₂ alone through contrail formation, cirrus cloud impacts, and NOx effects. The IPCC and GHG Protocol recommend applying a Radiative Forcing Index (RFI) of 1.9× to aviation CO₂ emissions to account for these high-altitude effects. VSME OS applies this multiplier by default, as does DEFRA/DESNZ 2026. This is increasingly required by CSRD auditors and science-based target frameworks. Some legacy calculators omit RF — if comparing VSME OS outputs to another tool that does not include RF, divide VSME OS flight figures by 1.9. Note: DEFRA 2026 (published 11 June 2026) again revised aviation factors, reducing short-haul by 31% and long-haul by 40%, reflecting post-COVID passenger load factor recovery. VSME OS uses these updated 2025 factors.

pkm = passenger-kilometre. To calculate: number of return trips × route distance × 2 (for return). Route distances can be found using flight distance calculators or IATA published city-pair distances.

5.3 Employee Commuting & Remote Working (Category 7)

Category 7 is the GHG Protocol's category for emissions from employees travelling between their home and their regular workplace. VSME OS covers two sub-categories:

Activity SourceUnitFactor (kgCO₂e)SourceNotes
Employee Commutingkm/year (all employees)0.16591DEFRA / DESNZ 2026Average car, unknown fuel, per km. Commuting is priced at the average-car rate — see the note below. Total annual km across all commuting employees.
Remote Working DaysWFH days/year (all staff)2.591DEFRA / DESNZ 2026kgCO₂e per WFH day (0.32393 kgCO₂e per FTE working hour × 8hr day). Covers home heating and office equipment.

Commuting note — read this before comparing years: commuting is priced at the average car, unknown fuel rate published by DEFRA / DESNZ 2026, which assumes the journey is driven alone. If your employees commute by bus, train, bicycle or on foot, this figure over-statestheir emissions, and the over-statement grows with the share of the workforce that does not drive. Until 4 September 2026 a blended "mixed modes" figure of 0.138 was used instead; it was withdrawn because it was not a published value and its derivation had not been recorded, so it could not be re-verified against any source. A conservative figure that can be traced to a published cell is worth more in a value-chain data request than a precise-looking one that cannot.

Remote working note: The 2.591 kgCO₂e/day WFH factor is the DEFRA / DESNZ 2026 homeworking factor — 0.32393 kgCO₂e per full-time-equivalent working hour, applied over an 8-hour day — and covers the additional home heating and office-equipment energy attributable to working from home. Successive values: 2.84 (DEFRA 2024) → 2.67 (DEFRA 2025) → 2.591 (DEFRA / DESNZ 2026). It is a UK-derived factor applied in every country; a country-specific homeworking factor is a future update.

Hotel stays — country-specific from 26 August 2026:Hotel emissions are now calculated using the country-specific factors published in the DEFRA / DESNZ 2026 "Hotel stay" dataset (kgCO₂e per room per night), covering 33 of the countries this tool supports. Until this date a single global figure of 28.0 was applied everywhere, which was not conservative so much as simply wrong in both directions: the published values span more than an order of magnitude, from Switzerland at 6.6 and France at 6.7 to India at 58.9 and Saudi Arabia at 106.4. Where DEFRA publishes no value— 36 of the supported countries, including Austria, Ireland, Poland and the Nordics — the previous 28.0 kgCO₂e/room-night estimate is retained as a documented fallback. It derives from the Cornell/Greenview Hotel Carbon Measurement Initiative (CHSB 2024, covering 20,000+ hotels). From CHSB 2024 onwards Cornell and Greenview no longer publish a single "all hotels" global average, as it can misrepresent results when one segment or geography dominates the dataset; 28.0 is a conservative practitioner estimate for organisations that cannot segment by hotel type. This creates a deliberate and disclosed discontinuity: a supplier in Austria is assigned 28.0 while one in neighbouring Germany is assigned 13.2 for the same hotel night. Every row of the PDF names the source actually applied to it, so the figure is traceable rather than uniform. Users with detailed hotel booking data are encouraged to apply geography- and segment-specific index values for greater precision.

6. Reporting Boundary and Exclusions

6.1 Organisational Boundary

VSME OS uses the operational control approach(GHG Protocol, Chapter 3). This means the reporting boundary includes all facilities and vehicles over which the company has operational control — typically the company's own offices, production sites, and owned/leased fleet vehicles. It excludes joint ventures and franchise operations unless specified.

6.2 What Is Currently Covered

Scope 1 ✓

  • Natural gas
  • Heating oil
  • Propane/LPG
  • Fleet diesel
  • Fleet petrol
  • Refrigerants (R410A, R32, R134a, R404A)

Scope 2 ✓

  • Grid electricity (location-based)
  • Renewable-contract electricity (location-based — same grid factor)
  • District heating
  • District cooling

Scope 3 ✓

  • Grey fleet (Cat. 6)
  • Rail travel (Cat. 6)
  • Short-haul flights (Cat. 6)
  • Long-haul flights (Cat. 6)
  • Hotel stays (Cat. 6)
  • Employee commuting (Cat. 7)
  • Remote working (Cat. 7)

6.3 What Is Not Currently Covered

Scope 3 Cat. 1 — Purchased goods and services
Scope 3 Cat. 2 — Capital goods
Scope 3 Cat. 3 — Fuel & energy-related activities
Scope 3 Cat. 4 — Upstream transportation
Scope 3 Cat. 5 — Waste generated in operations
Scope 3 Cat. 11 — Use of sold products
Scope 3 Cat. 12 — End-of-life treatment
Biogenic CO₂ emissions (land use change)

These categories are planned for future phases of the VSME OS roadmap. All currently excluded categories are explicitly listed as boundary exclusions in every generated PDF report (Page 4, Section 5).

7. Assurance Level and Limitations

Self-Attested (Limited Assurance)

Reports generated by VSME OS are self-attested— they reflect the activity data provided by the supplier and have not been independently verified by a third party. This constitutes "limited assurance" under ISO 14064-3. For many CSRD Scope 3 data collection purposes, self-attested supplier data is acceptable. For highest-tier reporting or where reasonable assurance is required, third-party verification should be engaged.

VSME OS does not independently verify the accuracy of activity data entered by suppliers. The calculation methodology is correct — but the output is only as accurate as the input data. This limitation is disclosed on every generated report.

Future phases will support integration with third-party verification bodies to provide independently assured reports where required.

8. Factor Update Policy

Current factor vintage

Full verification against official sources: 2026-04-23. Last staleness review: 2026-11-08.

Published but not yet applied

IEA Emissions Factors 2026 edition — published 2026-09-25

Affects: Grid electricity for countries outside the EU that cite IEA, and the world fallback

A licensed dataset. It will be applied once the licence is in place and each value has been read from it.

Cornell Hotel Sustainability Benchmarking (CHSB) 2026 — published 2026-06-01

Affects: Hotel-night fallback for countries without a DEFRA value

The 2026 public dataset gives averages by hotel type rather than one figure per country, so how to apply it is under review.

Declarations generated today use the verified factor set dated above. We do not apply a revised factor until it has been read from the issuing body's own published dataset, because an unverified number in a regulatory calculation is worse than a factor that is one cycle old. Reports state their factor vintage on the methodology page of the PDF.

Each primary source publishes on its own cycle. A newer edition that exists but has not yet been applied is listed above, never silently skipped:

DEFRA / DESNZ UK (2026)

Released 11 June 2026

Used for: UK electricity grid (0.14395 combined = generation 0.13096 + T&D 0.01299), UK district heat & steam (0.17529), UK national rail (0.03092), flights, grey fleet and remote working. Applied 26 August 2026 from the official full-set workbook. The steep fall in UK electricity is a DESNZ METHODOLOGY change, not only a cleaner grid.

ADEME Base Carbone V23.11

Released June 2026

Used for: All Scope 1 fuel factors (combustion only, upstream excluded); the French electricity grid (power-plant combustion plus network losses, upstream excluded, matching the UK treatment); French rail (Intercités traction, train manufacturing excluded). Each read by element id on 4 November 2026. French district heating and cooling are estimates under review: this edition publishes no national network average.

EEA (European Environment Agency)

Annual; 2024 data, 2026 release

Used for: grid electricity in 23 EU countries (greenhouse-gas intensity of gross electricity generation, CO₂e, no transmission losses). France and Germany use their national sources instead.

Other national grid factors

Under review

Used for: grid electricity in countries outside the EU without a source listed above. These values are being re-sourced from each country's official publication; the country's own row names what it cites today.

IPCC AR6 GWP100

Published 2021, stable

Used for: All refrigerant GWP values (WG1 Chapter 7, Table 7.SM.7)

Cornell/Greenview CHSB 2024

Annual

Used for: hotel night emission factor in the 36 supported countries DEFRA/DESNZ 2026 does not publish a value for. The other 33 use the DEFRA country-specific figure.

When factors are updated, previously generated reports retain the factors that were current at generation time (with version noted in the report). New reports use the latest available factors. The factor version and update date are disclosed in the footer of every generated PDF.

9. EU VSME Basic Module — What We Cover

The EU Voluntary Standard adopted on 3 July 2026 (Commission Delegated Regulation C(2026) 5011) sets out a Basic Module of eleven disclosures, B1 to B11. Paragraph references below are taken from Annex I of that regulation.

RefDisclosureCollected
B1 §27-28Basis for preparation Yes
B2 §29-31Practices, policies and future initiatives for transitioning towards a more sustainable economy Yes
B3 §32-33Energy and greenhouse gas emissions Yes
B4 §34Pollution of air, water and soil Yes
B5 §35Biodiversity Yes
B6 §36-37Water Yes
B7 §38-39Resource use, circular economy and waste management Yes
B8 §40Workforce — General characteristics Yes
B9 §41Workforce — Health and safety Yes
B10 §42Workforce — Remuneration, collective bargaining and training Yes
B11 §43Convictions and fines for corruption and bribery Yes

9.1 Every report states its own coverage

Collecting a disclosure is not the same as a given supplier having answered it. Each generated report therefore carries a Scope of this Report section listing every one of the eleven disclosures and whether it was reported, reported in part, declared not applicable, or not reported at all.

A report that does not cover the full Basic Module says so in those words. We would rather a buyer see the gap than assume there is none.

9.2 "Not applicable" is an answer, not an omission

Several disclosures are conditional. B4 applies only where the undertaking already reports pollutants to an authority or under an environmental management system; B5 only where it has sites in or near a biodiversity-sensitive area. Where a supplier positively declares that a disclosure does not apply to them, the report records that declaration rather than leaving the section blank.

The same is true of a conditional sub-point. B10 §42(b) asks for the gender pay gap only where the undertaking is already required to report it by EU law (Directive (EU) 2023/970) or national regulation. A supplier under no such obligation declares that, and the report prints the declaration — it does not print a blank where a percentage would be, and we do not ask them for payroll figures they owe nobody.

9.3 Proportionality at ten employees or fewer

Annex I marks B3 (energy and emissions), B6 (water) and B7 (resource use and waste) as voluntary for undertakings with ten employees or fewer, and Annex II places them outside the value chain cap at that size. For such an undertaking these disclosures are reported as not applicable, and from FY2027 a buyer may not require them for CSRD reporting.

9.4 Three datapoints a buyer may not require

Annex II lists, datapoint by datapoint, what a large undertaking may require from a supplier under the value chain cap. Three things VSME OS collects are not on that list: the employee breakdown by country (§40(c)), fatalities (§41(b)), and the gender pay gap (§42(b)).

We collect them anyway, because a supplier who gives them has a stronger declaration. But the product tells the supplier which of their answers a buyer can actually insist on — the cap is only a protection if you know where it sits.

9.5 What is outside the Basic Module

The Comprehensive Module (C1 to C9) is not covered as a module. The eight of its datapoints that are inside the value chain cap for suppliers with more than ten employees — C1 §46(a)-(c), C5 §58, C6 §61(a) and (c), C7 §62(a) and §62(c) — are asked on one optional page and appear in the declaration when answered. Scope 3 categories beyond business travel and employee commuting — purchased goods and services, upstream transport, use of sold products — are not quantified. Scope 2 is reported on both methods where a residual mix is published (section 4.2).

Questions about our methodology?

We welcome technical enquiries from ESG auditors, procurement teams, and sustainability consultants.